Nutmeg bakeshop is a husband & wife run small-batch bakery. We are also an ingredient-driven bakery (relying on premium, fresh, and seasonal ingredients), and we want that to be obvious! We believe that scratch-made is always better, so everything from our salted caramel sauce, to our lemon curd, to our candied pecans, are all made in-house.
When it comes to presentation, our philosophy is just as simple. We believe that cakes should look like cakes, and so we have no desire to build anything beyond delicious-looking. Though our products are always pretty, they are never fussy; their charm comes in the anticipation of eating them.
We bake bread, cookies, bars, cakes, and pastries - all handcrafted from scratch! So whether you prefer a perfectly humble butter tart, or the more sophisticated almond croissant, we’ve got something for you to indulge in and celebrate with.
256 Main Street South
Newmarket, ON L3Y 3Z5
monday : closed
tuesday : closed
wednesday : 10 - 6
thursday : 10 - 6
friday: 10 - 6
saturday : 8 - 5
sunday : 8 - 4
We like to bake with the seasons, so our menu is always rotating. Cookies, bars, scones, bread, and croissants are available everyday, all freshly baked and from scratch. We bake small batches throughout the day, so when we sell out of a particular item late in the day, that's it until tomorrow. Whole cakes are available upon order.
Please note that we are not a nut-free bakery, so any of our products may have come into contact with nuts. Also note that we are not a gluten-free bakery. All of our products (even the flour-less items), have likely come into contact with something containing gluten.
ALSO AVAILABLE IN THE SHOP